Transcript#

This transcript was generated automatically and may contain errors.

Hey there, welcome to the Paws at Data Science Hangout. I'm Libby Herron, and this is a recording of our weekly community call that happens every Thursday at 12 p.m. U.S. Eastern Time. If you are not joining us live, you miss out on the amazing chat that's going on. So find the link in the description where you can add our call to your calendar and come hang out with the most supportive, friendly, and funny data community you'll ever experience.

So some great questions today that I can give you to get us started. Are anything about community building? Because Rachel and I already have some things we'd love to chat about as a follow-up to our community building event that we had last month in early August. But also, anything about Conf? Anything about other organizations or the way that things work that you're just curious about? You could even tell them to me and I could put them up as a poll in Slido. In Slido, there's a little slider at the top where you get like a Q&A on one side, polls on the other. If we ask a poll, it'll be there.

Okay, so as an opener, my name is Libby. I'm a data scientist by training and trade, but I do community stuff here at Posit, which means I help all of us in the data science community come together. My background is applied stats, especially business statistics, operations research, mathematical optimization, all of the super boring stuff that nobody likes to do. I love that stuff. But I also love community building. I run our Discord server. So if you have not joined, there'll be links in the chat for that. And I will hand it over to Rachel to say hi and introduce herself.

Sure. So I'm Rachel Dempsey. I live in the Boston area, have been at Posit for almost officially nine years, which is wild. But yeah, I started off here on our sales team, made my way over to marketing and community. And that's where I've been ever since. So I lead our customer marketing team now. But I thought what might be interesting to talk about, Libby, is how the chaos mode started and became something that we're actually planning now. So for any community builders out there, you know, everything doesn't go perfect all the time. And for Hangouts, we always have like people lined up a few, like a month or so in advance. But sometimes someone gets sick and needs to reschedule or something comes up like travel. And we had a Hangout that was just like this chaos mode where we're like, well, everyone's still planning to get together at this time. So let's figure it out. And I feel like people just loved it. And then people were asking, like, when do we get to have another chaos mode again? So now Libby and I are trying to put them into the schedule once in a while too.

Heck yeah, I'm really excited about that. I'd also love if Isabella, you could introduce yourself. You all might know Isabella. And also Isabella, I feel like and Rachel are the only ones who do in person get together sometimes. I never do. So please feel free to mention that.

Well, sure. Hi, everyone. I'm Isabella Velasquez. So I've been at Posit for five years now. I can't believe it when it used to be called RStudio, hence the shirt. Before I came to RStudio Posit, I was a data analyst and so got to use a lot of R. I was living in Seattle at the time and one of the co-organizers for R Lady Seattle. It's an amazing time. I moved to Chicago a couple of years ago. And so really enjoying my time here. And I love being part of the data science Hangout community. So it's good to see everybody.

Excellent, excellent. And so Isabella is in Chicago. I'm in San Antonio, Texas. Rachel's in Boston. Boston and Chicago are like great places to be if you're in the data science community. I feel like so many people congregate in those areas. Texas is way more spread out and it's much, much harder to get people together. Texas is like where data communities go to die for some reason if they're in person.

Tom Mock is the founder of Tidy Tuesday in San Antonio, right?

He wasn't originally though. We acquired Tom. You know, it's hilarious as Tom and I, Tom Mock and I live in the same city and we've never met. We've got to fix that.

Mike's question: getting people to show up

I think Mike had a question right away. Mike, do you want to jump in here?

Can you hear me all right?

So this is for people who are kind of leading communities, either at their place of work or a user group or anything like that, where you're just trying to kind of bring people together. What do you do when it just feels like you're pulling teeth? Like it's a huge effort to even get there, get people there, get them talking. I know that there's the kind of rule of just show up, right? Where if you show up and if you get people along, that's half the battle. But sometimes it just feels like torture. And I'm wondering, you know, what can you do to either energize the group or keep things fresh or change things up? I mean, chaos mode is an example, I guess.

I mean, chaos mode, I will tell you, is somewhat anxiety inducing, right? Because there's like, there's no plan. It's up to you.

But then you see everyone jump in.

Yeah. What do you got, Noor?

So this is kind of a partial suggestion, may or may not work. But people like to know what they're getting into. So if there's some type of structure provided, especially with the type of people who tend to gravitate towards data science, they like having a plan coming in versus hi, we're just going to show up and meet, which is like, for me, who, contrary to popular belief, hates interaction, hates people, that sounds like my own miniature hell. So just knowing that there's like, okay, there's a formalized plan for this socialization, interaction, excellent.

And sometimes assist with that process.

I agree. Do you find that the Data Science Hangout has provided that? Like, what are some good examples, do you think?

I do like this. I like the Slido aspect. Since it's an online meeting and so forth, I like the Slido aspect, one, to see questions being asked and also see what other people are asking and get a vibe of like, oh, this is not a stupid question or, oh, these are what other people are interested in and so forth. And also the Slido aspect is nice. So like people who don't want to speak up but still have a question are also represented as well.

Yes. Okay. Noor just gave the answer that Rachel and I would have given, like, give people a way to ask questions in whatever way is comfortable for them, meet them where they are, right? Excellent, excellent. But also let people know what normal looks like. So in the beginning of the Hangout, I'm like, here's what we do, here's why we're here, here's how we ask questions, here's how this is going to go. Otherwise, everybody in the group is kind of sitting there wondering what they should be doing and afraid that they might do the wrong thing in front of a bunch of people, right? The best example of this is like, there's a bunch of cameras on right now. We are hanging out, we are like eating snacks, drinking tea, whatever. Camera on crew is representing hard today. But that's because over the course of five years, we have established that it's okay to have your camera on, it's okay to have it off. Libby and Rachel and whoever is talking are the only people who are going to end up recorded and on YouTube. This grid view of everybody is a pretty safe place to hang out and be. Just setting the norm is pretty good.

But Mike, to your question of how do you keep showing up when it's really, really hard? And is the only answer just to keep showing up? I think the answer for me is recruiting good people to show up so that you have friendly faces too as an organizer.

I think the answer for me is recruiting good people to show up so that you have friendly faces too as an organizer.

I hope your question was about being an organizer. Liz, Liz, what's going on? I hope you have me here.

Hi, that was a great question. I liked Nora's answer a lot too. And I thought it was very ironic that we're in chaos mode talking about having a plan. So I think that the question, that what this all makes me think of is trust. And it seems that this community has built a culture of trust. And so that allows for more chaos mode. But if you're in a situation where you haven't yet built that trust, then some of the things that I've seen or had some discussions with people about are things like doing improv, like building structure in a way that can be kind of uncomfortable, but still structured. And I don't know that improv is like the answer to everything. That's one example. But there are kind of other facilitation activities like I've seen facilitate, I've been in meetings with facilitators, groups of facilitators that they have some interesting ways of bringing people together in structured and having a little bit of chaos in between ways. I'm curious if other people have experiences like that.

Yeah, I'd love to hear from people because I have been in organizations where the structure is actually too structured. It's too much. It's like there's meeting minutes and they're planned out by the second and the minute. And if you reach minute 12 of the meeting, you're talking and you have two minutes to talk. And then we're going to cut you off at minute 17 and somebody else's turn. I find that for me, that's a little too structured and it can create this sort of like fear of hands lapping, right? Where like, if people don't feel like they can have any flexibility inside of your structure, they might not participate at all. And indeed, in a lot of those meetings, no one says a word. The chat is just like completely empty and dead. And that goes back to that safety thing you were just saying. Psychological safety is really important. Okay, Mike, I hope that that answers your question.

Community failures and changing format

Libby, I remember back in the day when we kept recommending the book Subtract. And I do think it's important to take a step back sometimes and think about if it is really hard to get people to show up to this thing, is it the right format? And if it feels like pulling teeth, why? And I just had a, I put in the chat, I want to celebrate some community failures as well, because I recently been trying to get people together from the pharma community for just some high-level talks that they wanted to have with each other. But I kept being so hard to get people to show up for the time that they wanted, like once a month. And sometimes people would be there and then it'd be like two months before they came back. And I just was honest with them to say, this feels like it's not working. And I know that you all wanted to meet with each other. So what do you think we should do? And like here's some ideas I have. And so now we have this new thing where we're helping people meet one-on-one with each other. And so they can say like, these are one to three topics that I'm really interested in. And this is my availability. Cause like, I know they want to meet with each other, but that monthly meeting just was not working. And I was starting to dread it. And I'm like, oh no, why am I like anxious about this this morning? I love it. Root cause analysis, even when it's uncomfortable, why is this not working? Why does this feel crappy?

As a reminder, everybody, I forgot to say this. You can upvote questions in Slido. So head over, even if you don't want to ask a question, go skim through some and like sneakily upvote the ones that feel good to you so that they rise to the top for us as well. And I actually do a shout out real quick.

Ryan is starting a new supply chain community and we just met this week to talk about it. And I just wanted to say, if anybody here is in the supply chain space and would be interested in like getting to start something new, it's a great opportunity to join Ryan on that. Ryan, sorry to put you like on the spot, but if you want to jump in.

Yeah. Ryan or Connor to Ralph's here, I think.

Hey everybody. Yeah. I'm happy to, to join in. And you know, this, these last couple of minutes of this conversation have been really interesting because well, I'll give a little bit of background. I had the idea to put this together maybe a few months ago to, to group up with some people in the supply chain community and then thought that I would run into a handful of people at the conf last week. And I think there were people there, but I didn't connect with a ton of them. And so I thought, well, let's, you know, let me talk with Rachel and Libby and see what we can do. And so that's, that's kind of the idea. And I think we would like to launch one in the next couple of weeks despite some of the conversation we just had about, are people going to show up to it? So I think we will go forward with it and I'm just trying to put together some ideas. And at the moment I have in mind this idea of doing kind of like lightning talks. So maybe there's a, this idea is less than 24 hours old, but maybe there's like a problem of the week or like a current event or, you know, what else could it be like a book review or help me with my resume.

And we'll do these topics and people can maybe sign up to talk about those from session to session. And so we would have like a little bit of organization about what's going to be covered. And then, you know, we just kind of run it and everybody gets their few minutes to talk about what they want to. And then we sign up for more topics the next time around.

Yeah. That sounds like an uncomf. I would Google uncomf if anybody is curious and uncomference is like, okay, we're all going to get together, show up with your topics, sign up, and then we will go through and vote on like whatever we want to do. There's different ways to do this different ways, different people, right. I've done it, but it could help figure out what people do want to talk about. Mike says an uncomf is a chaos mode conference. Hence why I absolutely love the concept. Some more ideas for that Ryan could be one of my favorites is like a confessional. Like what do you do that is that other people would tell you is wrong, but you do it anyway.

You're just unabashed about it and defend it. Right. Like, like I actually read things straight into the environment or I, I do, you know, I just do things that other people wouldn't do. And here's why I do this. Yeah. Mike Smith says, how do I do this? Wrong answers only. It's something that I'll get people talking. So everybody reach out to Ryan, if you would like to get in on the supply chain stuff. And if I can just, I see a question from Marcus in here that says, can you define the term supply chain, which is a great question? Because if I had to estimate, I would say probably like half of the world's population works some on some level in supply chain. So because this is kind of connected with Posit, it would be like people that work in any level of supply chain, whether it's like manufacturing or procurement or forecasting, or my own experiences in like the logistics and the actual freight movement part to demand planning, all of those where you're also involved on the data side and the data analytics side too.

Don't, you know, definitely don't want to be exclusive and it may result in us splitting out into, into, into different groups as time goes on. But that's I guess to answer Marcus question, how can you define the term supply chain? We'll see. But if you're inclined to come and you think you fit, just, just come. We'll make it work. Amazing. All right. Thanks, Ryan. Let's hop over to the slider where we have so many questions that we won't be able to answer them all unless we get going. I saw that Olaya had a question and Olaya, I hope I'm saying your name correctly and that we can find you and help you unmute. And I will put your question in the chat as well. If you'd like to ask it live.

Getting feedback from your community

Yeah. Hi. So yeah, I was wondering like how you guys deal with getting feedback from the community in not like a meeting way, but I'm thinking sort of like surveys that type of like online asynchronous feedback. What types of things do you guys do? And like, then what do you do with the data? How big is your group, Olaya? So I work for the preprint servers by Archive. I'm at Archive. So our user base is like 10 million people.

So yeah, we, but we're interested in hearing from both like authors who put preprints on our websites, but also people who just read preprints. And those are harder to track because like they come to our site, but we don't track them. We don't collect any data on them. They don't log in. So it's harder to reach people we don't really know are using our service and how they're using it. So in the past, we've done surveys where we email our authors because we do have an email for those people and then post on social media and hope for the best.

But we have struggled with getting a very biased sample because the people you reach and the people who are motivated to reply are kind of like the most engaged ones. So I guess as a follow-up, how do you reach the people who maybe use your products or participate in your community, but are not as like enthusiastic about it? They're just like, oh yeah, we use it, but like, I'm not a top advocate.

I think that this is a like two or three part question and concept. One being the definition of a community versus a user base, right? Because you've got like a super big user base, but are they a community meaning they know that they belong to the group, they identify with each other, they know who each other are, that was structured strangely, and they also like have a way to connect with each other instead of just you, right? Because you're in like a one-to-many communication situation instead of a many-to-many opportunity. So like in the chat here, Arsenis could talk to Mike, Renato could talk to Connor, Aaron could talk to Noor, right? Like we could all talk to each other. So when you've got a sort of user base question, it becomes a product question. Like where do you put that? You could put that, one example that I could give you from Rachel and I, is that we have a registration survey. So if you register for the Data Science Hangout or the Data Science Lab, you get asked questions, and so we have data that way. We have questions that pop up in a survey after each of our sessions and say like, how did we do? Did we do okay? Did you feel okay? Did anything go wrong? Things like that. Or what do you want to see in the next session? And that stuff could be really helpful where it's like, if you're putting the survey where people are using the thing, but that might not be something that's within your power to do. But then also, do you have an organization set up or a community set up where archive members can talk to each other? Because I don't even know. Some people said in the chat that they're happy archive users, by the way.

Yeah, no, but that's a great point. Like the difference between community and user base. And so I guess a follow-up to that, it's like, Posit is way bigger as an organization than we are. We're like 16 employees. But I guess what would be the people requirements to do something like this? Because in our current state, there's no way we could have a hangout like this. It's like, come chat with us and learn about rebrands, learn about the new features. I think I love that. I'm just like, my brain is starting to like, you know, all the things we could do. Literally cannot do them right now. Do you need a whole marketing department to be able to run these things?

Starting small and growing over time

I will say when we first started this, it was just the Zoom meeting. And I tried it and was like, oh, 20 people came on and that's great. And then tried to build it up from there. But I think starting small is great. It's not going to be 200 people right away or 150. But I don't mean the people coming. I mean, how many people you need to like, organize it? Like, how long was it, like, employee time to run it?

Yeah. I mean, it started with just Rachel. And Rachel wasn't even in a community-focused position. It wasn't like her full job or anything. It was like on the side. She was like, this sounds like something that would be beneficial, right? We could get people together to talk to each other. And she just started something, which is the advice I would give anybody. Like, get something on the calendar. Yeah. I think sometimes just, yeah, just getting started and not making it so it has to be this huge thing right away. Because it might be too daunting if we think about, like, needing to have had the full, like, data science hangout website and expecting this many people to come every week. Where I really just sent a few LinkedIn messages in the beginning to say, like, hey, we're going to try this thing. And I was wondering if you'd be interested in building it with us. And a few people came from the start. And some of those people are here still, like, five years later, which is amazing. So yeah. And I'm always happy to chat one-on-one if that would be helpful, too, about those early days. I feel like Marco's had a question about this in Slido, too.

I really just sent a few LinkedIn messages in the beginning to say, like, hey, we're going to try this thing. And I was wondering if you'd be interested in building it with us. And a few people came from the start. And some of those people are here still, like, five years later, which is amazing.

Yes. And we also have Nora and Mike with their hands raised. So I'm going to ask Nora to unmute and chime in here real quick, too.

Yay. I'm slightly biased because I have heard of BioRxiv, but I'm shamefully was not aware that they had a blue sky. So that's on me. That being said, have you also, I guess, BioRxiv connected with some of, like, the training organizations and, like, professional societies like ASHG and things like that? Because those also may be a good source, because often the people using BioRxiv are often trainees and so forth, or they're using BioRxiv and uploading their stuff and so forth. That may be a good way of reaching out to your user base as well.

Yeah, no, the Early Career Scientist is a great idea. We definitely, like, know that that is part of our user base and very engaged people. But, like, our main, and we had some projects sort of starting to try and reach those groups. But again, 16 employees is our biggest issue at the time. Um, so that's why I was like, how much effort does it take?

This is a good point, though. Yeah, because our main job is not this. Like, we are, our main job is not community management. And so do you at least need, like, one dedicated person?

I'm gonna say my vote is no. No. But you do need recognition from leadership that you are going to take the time and it's okay for you to invest the time and you can set some boundaries for yourself. So you can be like, okay, I'm one of 16 people, we are all pretty strapped for time. Is it okay if I take 10% of my week and put it towards this? And here's what I plan to do with that. And here's why I think it's going to be a good thing. And, you know, here's what feedback I think we'll get from it and how beneficial it will be. And that can be, you can set some pretty hard boundaries around that. You know, you can say, okay, here's what I plan to do. I'm going to set up a Google Meet event. I'm going to reach out to Libby and Rachel and get some advice on how this might work, right? And here's who I'm going to invite. I'm going to put an invite in this place where only, like, I think a hundred people might see it. And really just guard your time around it.

That way it can start small and it won't spiral out of control. And then you can come back to leadership after you've had the event and say, here's what I learned. Here's how valuable it was, or be open to, it was not valuable at all. I'm not, I'm never doing that again. Or, or it was super valuable. I would like to do more. How can I advocate for spending more time on it? Mike, you had some advice, I think. Would you like to unmute?

We're trying. We're getting there.

There we go. Yep. So, and Marcus is actually probably still in the thunder here. So, if you go back and look at Rachel's PositConf talk or RStudioConf, whenever it was, because it was a few years back, I think it depends, the number of people and the kind of scope of what you're trying to do, I think that this DSH is a bit more like regulars at a bar, right? You know, you come in and it's like, hey, how's it been going? What are you working on? You know, tell us what you've been doing. Rather than a kind of, hey, you're here to learn all about Posit products. And I think that that former thing of the community is actually just a bunch of people who regularly use these tools and want to get together and just share what they're doing and kind of ask questions and get some answers. It's as simple as that in my mind. And I don't think that needs a huge kind of infrastructure or, you know, even a terribly well thought out plan. Sorry, Rachel. Sorry, Libby. Hey, I don't think it was overplanned at the beginning.

I think that that former thing of the community is actually just a bunch of people who regularly use these tools and want to get together and just share what they're doing and kind of ask questions and get some answers. It's as simple as that in my mind.

No, not at all. Yeah, so just it's just some, I, okay, my red flag, though, is that I call everything an experiment so that people will say yes to it. And so I'm like, Oh, let's just try this experiment. So it was an experiment at first. But I, I will say that you will probably see the value right away. But it takes a little bit more time to help other people see the value of it. So it's not like things grow immediately and become like, become what they are immediately. It does take time and it takes effort. But I don't think that you need to have a full time person dedicated to it. Yep. And we, we didn't, I didn't work here for years before, you know, like Rachel did the hangout by herself for a really long time, with the support of other people inside, like Isabella, like, you know, people who would hop in and help. But, yeah, I was an attendee. And so

that's a great point as well. Mike was saying Libby was a cheerleader on the sidelines. Yeah, for a long time, I showed up, I helped grow the community. I really loved the space. And there are people who keep showing up here always. Mike is a cheerleader, James, Noor, No Tobacco shows up all the time. Natasha always asks amazing questions. Luke is here. Sometimes his background is on fire. And that's my favorite thing in the world. Just like people who continue to show up and ask cool questions.

Rachel reached out to me one on one, first or second hangout that she did said thank you for attending. And that can be one of the most impactful things that you can do. Reaching out one on one and saying hi to people and making friends. Because this is all about making friends.

Reaching out one on one and saying hi to people and making friends. Because this is all about making friends.

Okay, so let's, let's go on to another question in Slido here. And let's see, I wanted to go. Okay, sorry. Some things were jumping around. Marcos had a question. And I don't see an asterisk. Marcos, are you willing to ask live? I'll put it in the chat too.

There we go. I can unmute now. I think Rachel kind of already answered it. I was just asking about the early days, the data science hangout, like how small did you start? It sounded like you said you were messaging people on LinkedIn to kind of get initial attendance? Like was the first meeting 10 people? Was it 20? Like what what gave you the idea to do such a thing? I mean, you kind of already answered this, but anything else you want to say in that regard?

Good question. This is more specific. Yeah, no, I think it was.

So as we were, we were hosting a lot of meetups, and we'd have presentations, like we had R and insurance, or we'd like have a virtual meetup. This was even before COVID when there were a bunch of virtual meetups. But it was a way to get to share what different customers were doing. Because I was in sales. And people would ask me like, what's this customer doing? And I couldn't just say like, hey, this is what they told me on a zoom meeting. But then all of the q&a part was always like crammed into the very end. And it felt like that was some of the best parts is when people were just like jumping in and asking questions. And then the same with like hosting that are meetups in Boston, like in person ones, I always had great conversations with people when I was in the elevator, or when I was like grabbing pizza after.

And so this was to be all q&a, just open format the whole time. But I do think Rob Bethel, who used to work at RStudio and posit really was a person who helped like put a brand around it. So like we were doing these meetups, but we didn't have like, the idea for this being like a data science hang out. So he helped with that. But also, I still struggle with how do I get the word out about things? You know how like, any company who sends you something and it says, do you want to receive marketing emails? Like we always say no, we don't want to receive marketing emails, but the hangout and community events, they're marketing emails. And so I don't know how to let some people know about these things unless they see it on my LinkedIn or Libby's LinkedIn or on Blue Sky. So that's something I'm still trying to figure out. A lot of it, I think is word of mouth. So thank you all, everybody here for letting people know about the hangouts.

What do you think Libby?

I will say that in the early days, the way that I found out was LinkedIn. However, LinkedIn was a different place. So I think Olaya said in the chat that like, social media is part of of what you're trying to do. And it's hard.

Valid. It is hard. It's weird. It's a quagmire. The algorithms are feel very out of control. The people who actually follow you, whatever that means, can't see what you're posting. Often I'm like, hey, here's something that I'm doing, or here's something that's happening, or I'll post a question and like four people will see it. And you know, thousands of people supposedly follow me on LinkedIn, the follow count kind of means nothing in the grand scheme of things. So individual connections begin to mean more and more in that scenario, right? Where like, I can talk to Mike and be like, hey, Mike, can you post like on your internal teams that this is happening? So that the people who actually do data science can see it. And you know, I might reach out to Kevin and be like, Kevin, you work on a team with other people who do this and that. Do you want to like spread this around? Or do you know people and Kevin will be like, yes, I'm part of a listserv and I'll put that out there, right? Those things become, I think, more important.

Starting a community and facing the fear

Also, I just put a poll in the Slido for you. I'm doing this on behalf of myself and Hadley, who have been talking about the idea of submitting a posit conf talk being scary. And this is about community as well, because I, I feel like the nerves people feel around something are not always super justified, because they just don't know enough about the thing.

Starting your first community thing feels terrifying. Rachel and I are like, put it on the calendar. Just do it. Reach out to some people. And you're sitting there going, no, that feels terrifying. What if they say no? What if they don't show up? What if I'm there by myself? What if nobody talks, right? I feel like submitting a conf talk is really similar, where if you've never done it before, you don't know what the process is like, and it might feel scary. And we are just, you know, a week after conf. And I've talked to so many people who are like, oh, I wish I saw XYZ at posit conf. And I think, oh, well, have you ever submitted a talk? And they're like, no, no, never. I'm like, okay, well, you got to be the change you want to see in the world. If you want to see conf talks about XYZ, consider maybe pulling together a talk and submitting it, right? This is the same for community. If you want community, you've got to be community first. And often it takes that one person going, yes, I'm going to put the time towards this.

Community building takes real work

One of the questions that we see frequently is how do I make community self sustaining? How do I make it so that one or two people don't have to do a bunch of work and community just happens? And the answer, unfortunately, is that that's not super realistic. Somebody is doing the work, right? And the way I would love to reframe this is like, um, if you are, you want to experience holiday magic, how do I get holiday magic at my house without doing any work, without anybody hanging decorations, cooking, baking, planning a party, inviting people over, cleaning the house, right? Holiday magic is not going to happen. And it doesn't just happen. Someone's doing a bunch of invisible work. That's the same for community building. There are people putting in a ton of effort behind the scenes. And so if what you want is to enjoy community without doing the work of it and putting in the time, it's going to feel really incongruous. It's going to feel really hard. So I would anticipate that it is work, advocate for yourself that it is work, right? Like go to your, go to your boss and be like, this, this would be really amazing for all these reasons. Can I put this much time towards it?

There are people putting in a ton of effort behind the scenes. And so if what you want is to enjoy community without doing the work of it and putting in the time, it's going to feel really incongruous. It's going to feel really hard. So I would anticipate that it is work, advocate for yourself that it is work, right?

And then I think you'll feel a lot better. You'll feel less bamboozled by like, oh, how much work it is. Yeah. Just anticipate it being work. Thank you for the 19 votes we've had so far. The majority of people are saying that the idea of submitting a conf talk does seem a little scary, does freak them out a little. I encourage you to head over to the slides and vote some more. But for right now, let's head over and get a question from an anonymous asker that says, if I was starting a community, such as an evening meetup, what is the best way to get speakers?

Finding speakers for your community

What a great question. And also so many replies here. So Nor had said, if you're near universities, that's a great place to find speakers. Heck yeah, I agree with that. Make some friends with some professors. Also make some friends with some grad students who want to give lightning talks, right? Now I'm thinking of anybody who feels afraid of submitting a posit conf talk. What a great way to practice than my speaking at a local meetup. Absolutely. Also like come to a hangout like this and put in the chat. Hey, I'm thinking about submitting a conf talk. Has anybody done it before? Is it scary? And then they can let you know whether or not it is. I've submitted one. I was nervous. I got through it.

Luke says, there's a good number of local R user group organizers and former organizers in the data science hangout crew. Look for them. A couple of names to start. Javier, Ted Ladaris. Yeah, absolutely. Isabella and I, Rachel, like we can probably point out to you some people who generally are, you know, in the community giving talks, but also check out YouTube. Look for R ladies and R user groups and Python user groups and find these other people who are actively already giving talks or showing up and attending or organizing and reach out to them and just chat with them and see what's going on. Generally people share their contact information, their LinkedIn. You can look for them there. And if you reach out with a LinkedIn connection message that says, hey, I'm a fellow organizer. I'm trying to get people together I saw your talk on XYZ or ABC. I am trying to get together people to do something in the community and we would love it if you would come and chat with us. Like that can feel really overwhelming even to make that connection and to reach out. But I promise if you do like 10 of those, you'll probably get half the people responding and saying, yeah, I'm happy to. What are your dates that you have open? And then you'll panic and realize you don't have any dates set up. And this is where getting something on the calendar ahead of time is really helpful and just planning towards it.

Barriers to community building

We had a question here. From Noor. Noor, would you like to ask your question? Because I think we were just talking about how nerve wracking it can be to do certain things. Could open up a little discussion and I'll put it in the chat. I didn't mean to talk this much, but this is sort of a broad question. We've touched a little bit on it through this whole entire session, but what are common barriers? I know we've addressed them with them, like getting people to show up, getting people to talk, but other barriers to community building and initiation, especially of the community building. And how have you addressed them? What's worked? What's failed? And also what's a good starting number to start off? I know some people are like, you just need two people. And I'm like, no, that sounds awful. I can talk to someone normally. Just I need something a bit more.

I want to turn this around to everyone. What is a barrier that someone's facing right now? Yeah. Raise your hand. I would love, love, love, love. Also, Luke changed his background to be on fire and I couldn't be happier. Thank you, Luke. Mike says it depends on who those two people are, right?

I totally recognize that having two people does not feel like a community. It's just a start. Kevin? Kevin has something.

Yeah. I mean, a barrier I'm facing right now for my RNIR community is just advertising it. And it's hard to find time in your schedule to show up to events like this, or I was at the positive event that happened just before this one, the modernizing analytics and education. And it's just, it's hard to find the time when you are working to show up and promote your groups. So I think that's always a big challenge.

Yeah, absolutely. I will say it's the same barrier that Rachel and I face too. Not any different. Like, how do you find people and let them know about the thing that you're doing? It's tough. Any suggestions in the chat here would be fantastic, but also like letting everybody in the hangout know and asking them if they'll share. Great stuff. Mike, what do you got?

So I go along to an electronic music night here in Glasgow and it happens monthly. The organizers of that night have done an amazing job. They work super duper hard. They advertise the heck out of it. But what that means then is that when you go along, you kind of see the same faces month in, month out. And also, you know, it's like that in a way builds that community. And like, you feel a little bit guilty if you can't come. Like, I had a competing meeting with this one on today and I was like, oh, should I go to that one instead? But then I was like, I really feel the pull to actually be there for chaos mode at the data science hangout. And so I kind of flipped and went, never mind that internal work meeting. This is the place to be. And I think that kind of long-term, you just get that kind of, actually, I would feel guilty if I didn't show up here today.

That's the sweet spot, right? Because that's where you want, that's what keeps people coming. But I think the part is like, it's no small effort to actually keep reminding people and make, you know, sending out the invitations, making them feel guilty if they don't come because you've got a personalized invite. You all get reminders from us, right? There's a two-hour before the thing that's like, is this on your calendar? I added that because it fell off of everybody's calendar. That's such a good point, Mike. And I actually have the same thing with the music community in Boston that we're starting up and it's every Thursday and it's different songwriters that get together. And we try and share it on Instagram and get it out there every week. But we started posting pictures of the group of 20 people who are sitting around and listening to the music. And I kind of feel that guilt too, where I'm like, I want to be one of the people building it up. So if I miss one, I'm like, oh, then am I not part of this initial crew here? But yeah, and it's fun seeing, it's been a few months now, but now I'm starting to

hear other people talking about it. Like, oh, I saw that thing that you've been posting. And I feel silly posting it every single week, but I do. And over time people start to know about it.

And I think people need, I think Nora, you said this too, like people need to know what to expect. And for this one, like it's in like a random place and you don't know like how to get into it, like which floor is it on? So we're like taking videos and showing people how to get into the building, things like that are important. Oh my gosh. If there's no parking, I'm not coming to your event in person. Like, honestly, there are so many barriers that will keep people away that you have no idea exist for them.

And this is one thing that I was talking with Hadley about, about submitting Conf Talks. If you are a Conf Talk person, you've given a bunch of them, or you've written a bunch of blog articles, or you've done a bunch of things that are out in the open. Your brain is not in the mode of, this is a thing that intimidates other people because you're used to it. If you're the person who, you know, scouted out your in-person location, or you set up your Zoom event or your Google Meet event or whatever it is, it's all normal to you. You set it up, you know, all the details, but someone who is coming from the other side of it might be coming with a bunch of anxieties and fears and preconceived notions and questions that, you know, will keep them away from your event that you will have nothing, you will know nothing about. So all of that stuff, the wayfinding that you can do for people, it will be really helpful.

might be coming with a bunch of anxieties and fears and preconceived notions and questions that, you know, will keep them away from your event that you will have nothing, you will know nothing about.

Chat highlights and PositConf talks

Okay. So many freaking great questions. And I wanted to share some things that were happening in the chat. Allie Warren said, I want to recommend people submit positive conference talks. It was the most supportive experience I have ever had preparing for a talk. Amen. Absolutely. Me too. And I only gave a lightning talk at PositConf. Doing a talk at PositConf is transformative for a lot of reasons, because you learn how to give a talk and you are given a lot of support as a speaker in a group of people. Allie gave a virtual talk this year that was amazing and very well received. Thank you so much, Allie. It was a pleasure working with you.

But also Francisco had said, academia left me with scars. I feel like my projects, dashboards and implementations are nothing new or worth presenting. This is a fantastic example of what people are feeling on the other side of you asking them, hey, does anybody want to give a talk? They might be feeling this and I feel it too. Everything that I do is boring. It's not worth talking about. And that's the most common response I get when I ask people to be on the Hangout. They go, me? You don't talk to me? You don't want to talk to me. Nobody cares what I think.

Right. And then they come on the Hangout and they say, yeah, I just like do regression models. I don't know if anybody cares about that. And then the data science Hangout explodes with, what kind of regression models? I love regression models. Let's talk about regression for an hour.

OK, so your people are out there. They are more excited about the stuff that you do than you think. And they're more interested in whatever you do than you think you are.

Reaching people individually

But as an organizer specifically, understand that those scars behind the scenes, we all have them. We all grew up probably being told to be quiet all the time and or don't brag about things or nobody cares what you're talking about if you have a bunch of siblings like I do. So be cognizant of that. Rachel and I have found that the easiest way to get people engaged is to ask them specifically and individually to contribute. Because if you just say, hey, does anybody want to do this, which is also like asking for people to, you know, submit comp talks, it's this one to many invite that doesn't land on anybody specifically.

So going individually to five different people and asking them, hey, I have openings on these three days. I would love it if you could come and talk about something that's that you're working on lately or like a subject that you'd like to talk about or teach. What do you got? They're going to be much more likely to respond to that. We only have four minutes left. Does anybody have a follow up to that? I just talked too much, y'all.

Rachel and I have found that the easiest way to get people engaged is to ask them specifically and individually to contribute. Because if you just say, hey, does anybody want to do this, which is also like asking for people to, you know, submit comp talks, it's this one to many invite that doesn't land on anybody specifically.

Rachel, any anything extra? Okay. I'm going to go over to our questions and let's get one more in. Thank you so much. I just want to hang out with people all day. Like there's just so many questions we could keep going on. Can we just can we keep keep hanging out? Everybody just wants to work together for another hour.

Community shoutouts and Discord

I wanted to also shout out Shivani, who said that like, hey, this is a the discord has been really fun. And it's been a great place to like, share my stuff. Shivani shared her portfolio that she created, and she put a link in the chat. And I'm gonna like, I'm going to copy it here and like put it again so that everybody can go click it, go give it the hug of death really quickly and, and check it out. It's so fun, styled, like Windows 95. Really, really cute. Go play with it. And I agree, the discord is super fun. And if you have not joined, please join and hang out with us because we're there all the time.

I want to say also, it's a great place to ask questions like Monty. So Monty had asked a question. And I'm going to say Monty, please go ask that in the AI and LLM channel inside the discord. It says how do people personally stay optimistic and grounded while working with AI? How do you personally navigate that tension and avoid getting overwhelmed by the more pessimistic but very real narratives around AI? These are fantastic community questions that people have feelings about. And I am going to copy and paste, put it put it in the discord. And if you're there, I'll tag you. I would love to be able to talk with people about this at some point.

Yeah. Because I, I did notice a lot of like AI fatigue in the conference chat as well, as people were watching some talks, like, obviously, people are very excited about what is being announced and all the talks, but I did see that happening at the same time as well. So I think it would be really good to talk more about. Let's do it. And maybe we could even have some more smaller group chats and talk about it as well.

One thing to note, if you are thinking about AI fatigue and stuff like that, we were just talking about PositConf, the talks that get submitted are how the categories are created, right? So the talks that get submitted are what can be pulled from by the organizing committee to make the groupings. Posit doesn't ask ahead of time for like, Hey, we want AI talks. And then we want modeling talks. And then we want practical workflow talks. And then we want Quarto talks. We just like say, Hey, submit talks. And we see what comes in. So if a ton of people submit AI talks, and that's what they want to talk about, that's what the groupings end up including. So if you would really love to talk about things other than AI, please submit talks that are on those topics, because that's how we can create the schedule.

Wrapping up and next week's guest

Okay. I am so sad that we can't just talk for four more hours about all of these questions. I'm going to post some of them on the Discord server. Please hop on the Discord server and hang out with us. I will post them in the Data Science Hangout channel, but we also have a Community Builders channel. And I hope that you will hang out with us again next week.

And also, I will let you know who is hanging out with us next week. Y'all. Actually, while you're grabbing that too, I just want to say, we talked about community building a lot today. So I'm going to start a thread in here that is who wants to connect with other community builders one on one. Yeah, because we are starting to do that. And so maybe a few people have gotten to try it so far. But like I said, with the life science chats that we're trying, we can do that with community builders too. So you share your availability and we match you with someone. But you need to just let me know if you're interested in that.

And I lost the thread. No, okay. Zoom jumps around. Also, I found who's speaking with us next week. It's Dwight Berry. He's a Principal Data Scientist at Seattle Children's Hospital. If you know anything about Seattle Children's Hospital, you know that if you're in the Pacific Northwest, it's the place to be take care of kids. I personally have a friend whose kiddo gets tons of care at Seattle Children's and I think that they are a magical and wonderful place. So I hope that you come and learn all about Dwight. I love talking with him. I know that you're going to love it too. Dwight, oh, where are you? Raise your hand.

So I want everybody to meet Dwight, get to ask Dwight questions about his journey, his background, how he got to where he is, about Seattle Children's if you would like. He's a delight and I can't wait for you to meet him. So we will see you next week on Thursday. There's Dwight. Hey, Dwight. So good to see you. All right, everybody. Thanks for sticking a minute over with us. We love you. We'll see you next week. Bye.

Bye, everybody.

Bye.